ICYMI: Godzilla flattened the competition at the box office, which is generally what happens when you give him a city and two hours. “Godzilla Minus Zero,” from Takashi Yamazaki (“Godzilla Minus One,” “The Eternal Zero”), opened to $31.6 million in North America. The mighty nuclear lizard is already being considered among the best movie sequels in recent cinematic history.
I’ve already written about what Yamazaki learned from Cameron. Where the movie belongs next to “The Empire Strikes Back,” “The Dark Knight,” “Terminator 2: Judgment Day,” “Captain America: The Winter Soldier,” and “The Godfather Part II” can wait. Besides, last I checked, Godzilla can take criticism.
But all this Kaiju ballyhoo got me thinking: The worst movie sequels are a different night at the theater. One ripe with stomach growls, adjusting in your seat, and uncontrollable flatulence. We’re talking bad movies here.
You go to the theater hoping to see an old friend on screen, and come out wishing you’d stayed home to set up your CueCat. Any one of the many worst movie sequels can do that to a person. Did you ever see “The Crow: City of Angels” or “Son of the Mask”? If you did, you know they can arm wrestle over some of the last seats on the bus.
But these special ten get their own ride—a short bus, if you will. They squandered a decent idea, made the original harder to recommend with a straight face, or left a franchise in need of a long shower. A few even sold plenty of tickets. I hope everybody got their parking validated, because they all walked out of that theater praying the chains would offer refunds.
Here are the worst movie sequels, ranked from regrettable to unforgivable
Budgets are reported production costs. Box office figures are theatrical grosses in U.S. dollars, with domestic totals labeled where the cited records cover only the U.S. and Canada. Receipts for barf bags at these worst movie sequels were not included.
10. Staying Alive (1983)
Sylvester Stallone (“Rocky,” “First Blood”) took the kid from “Saturday Night Fever” and sent him to Broadway, where Tony Manero lands in a show called “Satan’s Alley.” Satan, it turns out, runs a vigorous aerobics program.
John Travolta (“Pulp Fiction,” “Get Shorty”) can still dance, even though it looks like a knee replacement happened between films. What’s missing is the Brooklyn kid whose Saturday nights meant something because the rest of his week was such a drag. The leg warmers are doing their level best to compensate. The Numbers records both figures, and yes, this thing sold tickets. Nonetheless, it certainly earned its way onto the worst movie sequels list. “To hell with the future,” indeed, Tony.
Budget: $22 million. Box Office: $126 million worldwide.
9. Grease 2 (1982)
Speaking of Travolta, the man eventually said yes to “Battlefield Earth” and “Gotti.” His absence here feels worth a moment of reflection about what other of the worst movie sequels he could make. He almost had his chance here, but said no. That should tell you something.
“Grease 2” sends us back to Rydell High, where Michelle Pfeiffer (“Scarface,” “Batman Returns”) wants a Cool Rider, and a bunch of teenagers sing about reproduction with the enthusiasm of people who just found out it’ll be on the test. There are people who love this movie. On “Cool Rider,” I’ll hear them out. For the rest, I’ve got bowling and a bad case of the earworms. (Try watching that movie and see if that God-forsaken song doesn’t crawl in your head and die.) AFI documents the reported budget, and The Numbers tracks its domestic run.
Budget: $13.2 million. Box Office: $14.3 million domestic.
8. Jaws: The Revenge (1987)
A great white apparently develops a personal grievance against the Brody family and takes it all the way to the Bahamas. Spielberg made people afraid of going into the water. The original literally shut down the travel season to the sandy beaches. By the fourth movie, the shark had my full permission to go in first and check whether the mechanism was working.
The franchise still drew paying customers. They were all insurmountably cheated out of their money. This movie was so bad, and it even featured Sir Michael Caine. The guy ended up doing well for himself in Hollywood, but thank God someone gave him a chance. Because this edition is among the worst movie sequels ever, it would have banished him. No bigger boat needed.
I’d have paid extra to see the shark explain itself at customs.
Budget: $23 million. Box Office: $51.9 million worldwide.
7. Speed 2: Cruise Control (1997)
Yes, Carol Burnett fans. The first face in the trailer is indeed Tim Conway. If that alone doesn’t tell you this should be in the worst movie sequels, nothing will.
The first “Speed” made a city bus feel like the fastest thing on Earth. For the sequel, somebody proposed a cruise ship, and evidently nobody at the table asked how long one takes to turn. Sandra Bullock (“While You Were Sleeping,” “Gravity”) returns. Keanu Reeves sits this one out (he was busy becoming “The One”), and the ship’s computer gets hijacked.
By the time the boat bears down on land, I’m rooting for the dock to get out of the way on its own. The reported production budget makes the whole thing even funnier, provided you didn’t finance it. You could say it was a train wreck, but that would probably give these dolts an idea for a third “Speed” movie.
Budget: $110 million. Box Office: $150.5 million worldwide.
6. Book of Shadows: Blair Witch 2 (2000)
Forget the forest and the found footage, kids. In this abysmal sequel, the world goes full emo. Blast on My Chemical Romance because this ain’t what the world expected to see.
“The Blair Witch Project” made a corner, a pile of sticks, and some fake lore enough to ruin a week’s sleep. The sequel follows fans of that movie into the woods, which might have been a good way to ask why everybody wanted a fictional nightmare to be real.
Director Joe Berlinger (“Brother’s Keeper,” “Paradise Lost”) later described the studio changes that reshaped his cut. (Yeah, Joe. Because that was the problem.) What reached theaters made fans miss the sticks. The sequel’s theatrical gross was real enough.
Budget: $15 million. Box Office: $47.7 million worldwide.
5. Mortal Kombat: Annihilation (1997)
The first movie understood the assignment. Get some fighters in a room, play that song and let people enjoy themselves. It was a video game movie, not too serious, but make it good. The sequel throws more characters at the screen than it has time to introduce, then turns its big finish into a fight between computer-generated beasts. And the CGI was so bad, Henry Cavill’s mustache cover-up in “Justice League” stood up and applauded.
I’ve spent enough years in martial arts to appreciate a good screen fight. I’d rather watch somebody at the dojo try to untie a stubborn belt than sit through those Animalities again. Or Raiden’s new hairpiece. I mean, really?! The sequel’s box office gives the finishing move a dollar value.
Budget: $30 million. Box Office: $51.3 million worldwide.
4. Batman & Robin (1997)
Batnips, anyone? Joel Schumacher (“The Lost Boys,” “A Time to Kill”) put George Clooney (“ER,” “Ocean’s Eleven”) in a suit that could tell you the temperature on set.
Arnold Schwarzenegger (“The Terminator,” “Predator”) turns up as Mr. Freeze and has enough ice puns to keep the concession stand running through August. The real shame is that there’s a sad story in there about a man desperate to save his wife. Good luck hearing it over the sound of Batman getting his credit card out. Somewhere, Tim Burton was even laughing, playing with action figures, at how campy this film ended up.
Budget: $125 million. Box Office: $238.3 million worldwide.
3. Superbabies: Baby Geniuses 2 (2004)
Never heard of this film? Don’t worry. No one else has either.
The depressing part of this toilet-bowl swirling film is that Bob Clark, who made “A Christmas Story” and “Porky’s,” was the ingenue here. Here is a man who understood both childhood and poor judgment, and still managed to dominate any list of worst movie sequels.
Then he directed a movie in which toddlers take on a media mogul played by Jon Voight (“Midnight Cowboy,” “Deliverance”). Rotten Tomatoes logged 46 reviews and zero positives. You couldn’t get 46 adults to agree on a pizza topping. This movie brought people together—straight for the stalls in the bathroom. The Numbers has the receipts.
Budget: $20 million. Box Office: $9.4 million worldwide.
2. Superman IV: The Quest for Peace (1987)
Dear God, the original Man of Steel and the great Gene Hackman deserved a better last flight
Christopher Reeve is set on a quest to create the world’s worst public service announcement. His goal is to rid the world of nuclear weapons, which is a perfectly good dilemma for a man powerful enough to do it and decent enough to wonder whether he should.
The movie gives him Nuclear Man, a blond fellow whose fingernails do a surprising amount of the dramatic work. By the time Superman takes the fight to the moon, the special effects appear to have gotten there on a separate budget. The only peace anyone who dared to see this film was given was that this movie has an ending.
Oh sure, the stars tried to make it good, but if you ever need a good laugh…like seriously morose, watch the duel on the moon. It looks like two overgrown kids in superhero underwear playing in a ball pit at a nasty fast food restaurant.
Budget: $17 million. Box Office: $36.7 million worldwide.
1. Highlander II: The Quickening (1991)
There should have been only one.
The original gives us immortal swordsmen, centuries of grudges and Queen. The theatrical sequel gives you an elderly Connor MacLeod, an artificial shield around Earth, and a planet called Zeist. What? Scientology needed a film, so they hijacked this?!
How do you get from sword fights in the Scottish Highlands to an argument about the ozone layer? I don’t know, but somewhere around Zeist I began to worry that the mozzarella sticks were coming back for a sequel of their own. AFI puts the final cost at $34 million. Box Office Mojo records the domestic gross, but there wasn’t much to see here.
It definitely tops the worst movie sequels list because of the lore, the hype, the potential. And all of it was squandered for a script written on a BBQ-stained napkin at McDonald’s. No one deserved this pain. The head of this movie should have been lopped off decades ago.
Budget: $34 million. Box Office: $15.6 million domestic.
Add us as a preferred source on Google.
